Subscribe to the blog

Double Peanut Butter Cup Cookies

Double Peanut Butter Cup Cookies by

These delicious little peanut butter cup cookies were almost never created…we were supposed to bring something sweet with us to a friends house and we settled on some store bought little treats from one of our favorite stores. Well, the mini peanut butter cups melted! What could one do but make cookies?? So we put the melted peanut butter cups in the fridge and set out to make these beauties while they firmed up.

My family couldn’t help but try a few before we headed out to our friends home…thankfully, this recipe made plenty!

I never thought I would say this, but I am SO happy that they melted! Of course, you can also use “non melted” mini peanut butter cups too…those would be delicious as well! 🙂

Dive in and try them out! They would even be the perfect Valentine’s Day treat for your favorite chocolate and peanut butter fan!


I hope you enjoy these cookies! I know we did!


Double Peanut Butter Cup Cookies by

29 Responses

  1. Yum, I love peanut butter cups, and I love cookies! Pinning!
    Jamie @ Coffee With Us 3 recently posted…Crockpot Recipes Saturday DishesMy Profile

  2. Monica says:

    Delicious! YUM!

  3. Megan says:

    Mmmm!! These sound Amazing!! I LOVE peanut butter cookies! I’m totally going to try this recipe! Thanks for sharing!
    Megan recently posted…Valentine’s Day Card TutorialMy Profile

  4. These will be devoured in my house. The husband is a HUGE peanut butter fan!! Love the chunky cookies.

  5. Felicia says:

    I have to admit that peanut butter cookies are probably my favorite cookie of all time. But double peanut butter cup cookies may take its place! This recipe looks absolutely delectable and just in time since I’ve been craving peanut butter cookies lately. Thanks for sharing, I can’t wait to give this a try! 🙂
    Felicia recently posted…First Trip to Niagara FallsMy Profile

  6. Herchel S says:

    These look delicious! I am definitely going to try these. Peanut butter cups are my husbands favorite!
    Herchel S recently posted…I’m not a very good tooth fairy. But there’s hope…My Profile

  7. Hakima says:

    Cookies are soo yummy! My son loves peanut butter so he would eat these up!

  8. erica says:

    Oh these look so delicious! I am a sucker for peanut butter. Pinning this to make this weekend! Thanks for sharing 🙂

  9. Elle says:

    We do love peanut butter cups and I am sure my husband would love these cookies, too!
    Elle recently posted…Taking Time to ReflectMy Profile

  10. Ida says:

    OMG! These sound and look so delicious. I pinned this recipe so I can make as a yummy Valentine’s treat!

    Stopping by from your SITS girls comment love group! I am now your newest follower! I want to make sure I don’t miss any recipes!

  11. These look absolutely delicious! (And I like that you used whole wheat flour…we can pretend they’re healthier!)
    Emily @ Words I Wheel By recently posted…4 Lessons Peacocks Can Teach Us About AdvocacyMy Profile

  12. These sound delicious! Love the addition of whole wheat flour. I may try your recipe substituting coconut sugar for the regular….

    Stopping by from SITS Challenge !
    diane padoven recently posted…Italian Chicken Stew with Olives and KaleMy Profile

  13. Divya says:

    Wow they look so delicious ! Would definitely give them a try. Pinning it 🙂
    Stopping by from SITS Girls.
    Divya recently posted…Minimalist MondayMy Profile

  14. Erin says:

    Ummmm well since single pb cup cookies would be amazing, double is automatically a win. Pinning so my husband can make them for me! 🙂

  15. Hollie says:

    These are one type of cookie I haven’t made. Super easy recipe too, which is a win. Can’t wait to try these out.

  16. I LOVE peanut butter and peanut butter cups even more! I really miss delicious desserts like this but my little one has a ton of food allergies so I can’t make this. I know I would love it though!
    Holly @ My Plant-Based Family recently posted…Meal Plan Monday: Change of (Meal) PlansMy Profile

  17. Wow these sound absolutely sinful!!! Thanks for sharing the recipe! #SITS comment love <3
    Heather @floridafitnessmom recently posted…Motivate Me Monday: 2/10My Profile

  18. These cookies sound so yummy!! And…I had never heard of ZipList before so I am double excited! Thanks for sharing!

    • Diane Marie Haller says:

      Thanks so much Heather! I am really enjoying Ziplist! I just started using it this past week and it has been great!

  19. Yum! These sound delicious! I am pinning these. Coming from the SITS Comment Love!
    Emily @ Love, Pasta and a Tool Belt recently posted…Cinnamon Roll Pound CakeMy Profile

  20. Heather Larson says:

    Yum! These sound delish:)

  21. Ginnie says:

    Chocolate and peanut butter is my favorite combinations, and these look so delicious! Thanks for sharing. P.S. I’m in your SITS Girls Comment Love Tribe:)
    Ginnie recently posted…Indoor S’mores – 3 Ways!My Profile

  22. Hi Diane! These sound SO good and look so pretty! My hubby is like a peanut butter cup fiend so I know he will love these (plus he’s a cookie monster, too!) Thanks so much for sharing and pinning! Have a happy Tuesday!

  23. christine says:

    These look awesome. Pinned!

  24. Jamie @ Love Bakes Good Cakes says:

    I think these would quickly become a favorite! Pinned to try!

  25. Sarah Fuller says:

    A yummy delight for Valentine’s Day. There can never be too much peanut butter for me.
    Sarah Fuller recently posted…4 Good Sources of Government Job OpeningsMy Profile

  26. Esther says:

    I LOVE the combo of chocolate and peanut butter. These are the perfect snow day cookies! Comment Love from SITSGirls! Can’t wait to check out your other recipes!
    Esther recently posted…Meghan’s Bathroom is Better than Pinterest!My Profile

  27. Emmy says:

    Peanut butter cups are my weakness! This recipe might just do me in 🙂
    Emmy recently posted…If My Daughter Were PresidentMy Profile


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers